Skip to main content

Harry Potter is fictional, but Achilles and Beowulf -- perhaps not

In a soon-to-be-published paper, physicists present an analysis that they claim can tell us which mythical heroes may have been based on real people, and which are entirely made up.

Beowulf and the Dragon, by J. R. Skelton
It is possible that a man named Achilles really did once sail across a wine-dark sea to his death, and a Nordic warrior named Beowulf really lived and fought, although it is highly unlikely he ever slew a monster.

Using the same mathematics that makes Facebook work, researchers at Coventry University of England analyzed three legends, Homer's "Iliad" (written around 800 B.C.), "Beowulf" (written around the 8th century A.D.), and an Irish epic, "Táin Bó Cuailnge" (perhaps 12th-14th century A.D.), and used social network analysis to see if real events might be behind any of them.

They found the characters in the Iliad and Beowulf were consistent with people in social networks; Táin less so.

Then they took works of unambiguous fiction and used the same analysis and found differences, but perhaps a hint about what makes great fiction.

The researchers are applied physicists, not humanities academics, and this kind of research is not necessarily embraced by all humanities scholars.

They started by sitting down and reading each work, said Padraig Mac Carron, a graduate student and lead author of the study.

Besides the three fables, they studied Victor Hugo's "Lés Miserables," William Shakespeare's "Richard III," J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Fellowship of the Ring" from the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the first of J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter books. They then marked each character and the characters with whom they interacted. The algorithms are from social networks, a relatively new field of computational science.

"A network is a group of nodes, and each node can be linked to another node and that is called an edge. An edge links nodes. In social networks, the nodes are represented by people and an edge is an acquaintance or some form of friendship," Mac Carron said. The number of links is called a degree.

"In Facebook, the number of friends you have would be your degree," Mac Carron said.

They marked every node, edge and degree. Some books took a day, some took weeks to get into the database.

Other scientists doing similar work just upload the text into a computer, but Mac Carron said he and his advisor Ralph Kenna thought doing it by hand was more effective.

First they tackled the three legends, marking each character to see how popular they were by measuring links and degrees throughout the whole work. They found 74 characters in "Beowulf," 404 in the "Táin," and 716 in the "lIliad."

They also measured whether the links were friendly or unfriendly, something a computer would have problems doing, Mac Carron said.

Then the researchers checked assortativity, the tendency of one character of a certain degree to interact with characters of similar degrees, a measure of popularity. They looked at vulnerability, which meant if you took that character out of the story does the story collapse?

They found in the "Iliad" and "Beowulf" that the tales followed the same patterns found in real social networks, indicating they could be based on facts or might be based on real characters, embellished over time. In the case of the Irish story, the storytellers probably were combining characters.

The use of this kind of computer analysis is controversial in the humanities, part of an academic culture clash.

David Elson and a team of researchers from Columbia University's computer science and English departments, developed social network analysis tools for 19th century English novels, such as the works of Charles Dickens and Jane Austen. They found their interpretation of the relationship between characters differed from conventional analysis.

"There's a flood of literature that's becoming machine-readable for the first time," said Elson, who now is at Google. "The amount of literature out there even in a single genre or historical period is far greater than what any critic could read in a lifetime. Computer-aided work on literary analysis is a way we can find insights into our literary heritage and our culture at large, without giving up the 'close read' for the texts we want to look at more deeply."

Joseph Nagy, an English professor who specializes in folklore at UCLA, said he wasn't surprised with the findings.

"Myths may be inspired by historical realities or reanimated by them," Nagy said. "It's a two-way street, but myths are not distorted, poorly understood, or misremembered history."

They are, scholars think, telling us what we want to hear, which may explain what Mac Carron and Kenna found.

Even the ancient singers, who told the stories of Achilles and Beowulf before they were written down, understood social networks long before computers and algorithms, said Timothy Tangherlini, professor of folklore at UCLA who specializes in Nordic epics. They tinkered with the tales to please their audience.

"They validate tradition," Tangherlini said.

For instance, the stories are jammed with complex genealogies, but many of them may have been invented by the singers to please sponsors, some of whom wanted to be related to heroes. Over time, they may have been incorporated into the text.

Verisimilitude was demanded; that's what the audiences wanted to hear, and the best singers aimed to please.

Mac Carron and Kenna are heading to South America to do similar analysis of local myths.

The article will be published in the journal Europhysics Letters.

Joel Shurkin, Inside Science News service

Joel Shurkin is a freelance writer based in Baltimore. He is the author of nine books on science and the history of science, and has taught science journalism at Stanford University, UC Santa Cruz and the University of Alaska Fairbanks.


  1. Great,

    I am obsessed for Harry Potter and was waiting for this great post, it's amazing for me and my children.

    Great Job on the costume!

    Boys Harry Potter Costume

  2. As for Harry Potter: A senior person from the British 'Association of head-teachers' expressed concern about the effect that the teaching / reading of these stories in class hours might be having on kids' curiosity regarding 'The Occult'. Go do the search:

    On Beowulf, clearly the author is a fan of Star-Trek and the Voyager episode based on Grendel and the Dragon. But I recommend reading "Beowulf" - The 1972/73 Penguin Classic short paperback by Michael Alexander with full translation of the The Poem and analysis. It's got absolutely everything including Family Trees, and deep contemplative analysis of many issues around the origins, contemporary and past significance, and the legacy of the Beowulf Epic.

    The book was completed with help of a grant from the Ford Foundation and the National Translation Centre in Austin, Texas enabled the author to dedicate the necessary time to research in the British Library.

    Worth checking out for serious research of 'Beowulf', in my Opinion.


Post a Comment

Popular Posts

How 4,000 Physicists Gave a Vegas Casino its Worst Week Ever

What happens when several thousand distinguished physicists, researchers, and students descend on the nation’s gambling capital for a conference? The answer is "a bad week for the casino"—but you'd never guess why.

Ask a Physicist: Phone Flash Sharpie Shock!

Lexie and Xavier, from Orlando, FL want to know: "What's going on in this video ? Our science teacher claims that the pain comes from a small electrical shock, but we believe that this is due to the absorption of light. Please help us resolve this dispute!"

The Science of Ice Cream: Part One

Even though it's been a warm couple of months already, it's officially summer. A delicious, science-filled way to beat the heat? Making homemade ice cream. (We've since updated this article to include the science behind vegan ice cream. To learn more about ice cream science, check out The Science of Ice Cream, Redux ) Image Credit: St0rmz via Flickr Over at Physics@Home there's an easy recipe for homemade ice cream. But what kind of milk should you use to make ice cream? And do you really need to chill the ice cream base before making it? Why do ice cream recipes always call for salt on ice?